I.
The “effective altruists should be more concerned about PR” brigade has been out in full force on X recently. For example, the Center for New Liberalism (which is generally EA-sympathetic) wrote:
Now, FTX and Situational Awareness (presumably not the essay but rather the hedge fund that collapsed [ETA: had a really bad quarter but is still going, thank you Andrew Hunter]) are both a fair cop. I too wish I had a magic button that would stop effective altruists from starting hedge funds.
“The movement is the modern day Christianity” is I think a reference to this tweet from Scott Alexander—
—which is a JOKE. J O K E. JOKE.
There has not been a movement in the history of the world that managed to keep everyone in it from making edgy jokes in publicly available fora. If the socialist movement could take over multiple countries in spite of Oscar Wilde opining that we need socialism because poor people are ugly of body and soul, I believe in effective altruism’s ability to survive Scott Alexander’s X feed.
But I think veganism, AI welfare, and polyamory are more serious issues, and I want to talk through why I think effective altruists should continue to care about AI welfare, reduce animal-product consumption as much as is practical, and have whatever relationship style they prefer.
II.
Effective altruists were right(ish) about AI in 2015, but not because they had access to the world’s first effective Magic 8-Ball, or because a fairy appeared in a burst of sparkles and whispered in their ears while they were sleeping. Effective altruists were right(ish) about AI in 2015 because we had particular thought processes and habits of mind, which gave us the right answer on this question.
No one who warned about existential risk from AI was doing so because they were concerned about popularity, public relations, and appealing to the Median Voter. People who worried about those things gave focus-grouped and poll-tested statements about how we need to make sure that all Americans learn to code so that we can be Prepared for The Economy of the Future in which we have automated all jobs except programmer—and they were all wrong.
As far as I can tell, the argument here is “so, you guys were right years before everyone else about what is shaping up to be one of the most important political and ethical issues of our time. You were right even though everyone was laughing at you and calling you apocalypse cultist weirdos and saying that you needed to shut up about it for PR purposes. By vocally caring about this issue before anyone else, you wound up with a lot of ability to influence it, hopefully for the better. So now, when people are laughing at you and calling you anti-human cultist weirdos and saying that you need to shut up about different things for PR purposes, you should definitely listen and take me seriously!”
Here are two things that, in my opinion, are far more obviously true than “AI risk is a big deal” was in 2015:
Factory farming is an ongoing moral atrocity of incomprehensible scope under every mainstream system of morality. The only reason it survives is that people are avoiding thinking about it because they want to eat tasty and inexpensive animal products. If you cast a spell that made everyone actually get what was happening on factory farms, industrial animal agriculture would end tomorrow.
We are very confused about consciousness and moral patienthood. We are also very confused about how modern AI models work. Modern AI models straightforwardly pass the Turing Test. If you showed a modern LLM to someone back in 1995, they would say “oh, this is a conscious computer like C-3PO.” I’m not saying LLMs are definitely conscious, but if you dismiss the question of AI moral patienthood completely out of hand, you are being the villain of iconic Star Trek episode The Measure of a Man.
By vocally caring about AI welfare and factory farming, effective altruists can potentially make progress on these important issues, and so save billions of farmed animals and digital minds from horrific mistreatment.
Look. Once you have already had an enormous victory for the cause of Think With Numbers and Expand Your Moral Circle and Be Prepared To Be Weird If That’s Where The Evidence Takes You, you shouldn’t abandon quantitative reasoning, moral circle expansionism, and the willingness to be weird. It’s time to double down! It’s clearly working!
III.
But polyamory?
I don’t think “everyone in effective altruism has a normal dating life” is going to do that much for public relations. Most people have bigger worries than San Franciscans’ scandalous dating lives (bit of a ‘dog bites man’ story, really). And the New York Post is clearly willing to run articles like “Daniela Amodei and her husband adorably talk through their life problems together using a council of stuffed animals” and “some women who work for METR have short hair.” Even if everyone in the effective altruism movement saved themselves for marriage and had vanilla missionary-position sex with the lights off, the people with a slavering hatred of effective altruists would find some other innocuous thing to be mad about. Like, these are the people who literally claim that effective altruists are starting cult compounds because many effective altruists have roommates.
At the same time, I don’t think most people who recommend “all effective altruists should become monogamous” are thinking clearly about how this is supposed to work. Let’s say that every effective altruist suddenly agreed that they should become monogamous for the sake of effective altruist PR:
An effective altruist woman is happily married to a man who isn’t an effective altruist, but who married her under the understanding that they’d be poly and who has absolutely no intention of closing the relationship. Is she supposed to divorce her husband?
An effective altruist man and an effective altruist woman are happily married, but he’s asexual and they agreed that she could have sex outside the relationship. Their relationship is happy, but he would be miserable having sex and she would be miserable being celibate for the rest of her life. Are they supposed to divorce?
Three effective altruists are married. Who gets divorced?
Four effective altruists are not married but are raising their children together. Are they supposed to split the children into two households, separating their children from their other parents and siblings?
Two high-earning effective altruists financially support their shared partner, who is disabled and can’t work a job. Are they obligated to throw him out on the street? (Perhaps they’re only obligated to stop having sex with him and not to stop financially supporting him. Which of “your sex life” or “your weird household financial relationship” is generally more obvious to the New York Post?)
A man’s secondary partner is a ridiculous workaholic who never takes breaks, so he’s her entire support network. Is he supposed to dump her? (Will we get a ruling from the Grand High Council of Effective Altruist Poobahs about exactly how emotionally intimate a relationship can be before you count as “polyamorous”?)
I can literally keep doing this all day.
Polyamory and monogamy are both sticky because people make commitments on the understanding that they will continue to have a certain relationship style, and switching relationship styles often means breaking your commitments. Of course, you can in serious situations break your commitments. If polyamory (or monogamy) is making you absolutely miserable, you are under no obligation to continue to do it just because your partners are expecting you to.
But in general if someone you love is relying on you to do something, you ought to do it! If someone has made life plans under the reasonable expectation that you would stay married to them, raise children with them, financially support them, or even just continue to be a loving presence in their lives, you are supposed to do that unless you have a really damn good reason not to. And “the New York Post might be mad at me” is not a really damn good reason.
It’s true that people who haven’t made any commitments could switch to being monogamous. But there are already a lot of monogamous effective altruists and it doesn’t seem to have stopped anyone from posting. As long as poly people are overrepresented in effective altruism, people are going to complain about polyamory in effective altruism. And the usual case is that people have made commitments that they’d have to break if they changed relationship style, because most of the time when people are in long-term loving relationships they make some kind of commitments to each other, and that doesn’t change if you’ve got more than one.
I am assuming here that everyone is magically convinced by the arguments. But in reality that would never happen; you’d have to set some kind of social norm. Can we just think concretely about what that means? What you’re saying is “your friends should tell you to break up with your girlfriend, who brings you joy and makes your life shine, if she happens to have a sex life Middle America would disapprove of, because the approval of random strangers is more important than love.”
Like. No? Fuck you? Watch more Hallmark Christmas movies and straighten yourself out.
IV.
Everyone who devotes their life to a claim that 99.9% of people think is ludicrous is a fucking weirdo.
First- and second-wave feminists were disproportionately lesbians (a sexual minority far more maligned at the time than poly people are today). John Woolman—one of the most prominent early abolitionists—spent much of his life wearing only bleached-white clothes because of his unusual interpretation of Revelation. You see this with weird ideas that have nothing to do with morality, too—for example, a founder of the Jet Propulsion Laboratory was a polyamorous Thelemite occultist who attempted to incarnate the Whore of Babylon with the help of L. Ron Hubbard. Over the long arc of intellectual history, effective altruists seem if anything unusually normal.
This is perfectly expected if you think about it. People who are willing to defy society’s norms in one way are also willing to defy them in other ways. If you’re the kind of person who says “women and men should be equal” or “slavery is a serious moral wrong” even though everyone makes fun of you, you’re also the kind of person who says “there’s nothing wrong with being gay” or “I should wear bleached white clothes at all times” even though everyone makes fun of you.
And moral and intellectual trailblazers are extremely high in Big Five Openness—that is, creativity, curiosity, and intellect. But people who are high in Big Five Openness also tend to be neophiles: they’re going to speak ancient Greek, take up circus arts, read all the classics of Ukrainian literature, try durian, learn to forage mushrooms, and (yes) have weird sex. And they tend to be tolerant, to value freedom, and to question tradition and orthodoxy. So you are far less likely to convince them that they ought to do something solely because everyone else is doing it or because society says it’s good.
Now, I’m not saying that you shouldn’t cut your hair and put on a suit if you’re going to testify before Congress. (Or buy a really good wig and put on lipstick, depending on gender.) Nor am I saying that you can’t be curious, intellectual, and creative and also an intolerant conformist who hates new things. While the facets of Big Five traits are correlated on a population level, individuals can be high in one facet and low in another. For example, all effective altruists are high in Altruism and low in Tender-Mindedness, even though these are both facets of Agreeableness and correlated in the general population.
I’m also not saying that people have to be poly to do good intellectual work. Many freedom-loving neophiles are monogamous, including effective altruist freedom-loving neophiles. The specific weirdnesses of the effective altruist community are mostly a historical accident. We could have just as easily all been furries.
But in general posts like the Center for New Liberalism’s are asking for fried ice. You can’t get groundbreaking moral and intellectual work without the kind of people who produce groundbreaking moral and intellectual work. Those people are individually kind of weird, and when you put a bunch of them in a group with each other their weirdness feeds on each other and they get really really weird. Fortunately, we as a society have solutions to this problem, like the existence of professional people wearing suits who can take the weirdos’ ideas and repackage them for general consumption. “Everybody stop being weird right now!” doesn’t work and has never worked and you should stop annoying me by calling for it.




Have you ever written a post on the claim that EAs were right about AI? If so I would like to read it. The impression I got in 2015 was that people thought we would be either living in a robot utopia by now, or all dead. This slow dragging enshittification of everything is not the apocalypse I was promised. But perhaps there was someone out there saying true things that I didn't hear over the sound of other people over-promising.
I think that when one's ideas are unpopular, they're going to get hated on for irrelevant things regardless of whether they're actually that weird. Mary Wollstonecraft was completely discredited when people found out she'd had a baby outside of wedlock. It wasn't that unusual, but people were up in her business to an unusual degree. So at some point you've gotta live your lives and hope the criticism sounds as nasty and mean spirited to everyone else as it does to you. (Seriously, nothing can undermine a point like "look at those WEIRDOS, they have weird sex!" instead of an actual argument.)
This is something I'd been thinking about recently and I was floundering for how to put it, but you put it much better than I could've.
Recently I saw a tweet (forget the author) who said something like, "I have a lot of respect for EAs for making predictions I thought were ridiculous at the time, but then turned out to be right. I just wish they'd stop making ridiculous predictions!" And I was just like, can you hear yourself right now?