Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sheila's avatar

Have you ever written a post on the claim that EAs were right about AI? If so I would like to read it. The impression I got in 2015 was that people thought we would be either living in a robot utopia by now, or all dead. This slow dragging enshittification of everything is not the apocalypse I was promised. But perhaps there was someone out there saying true things that I didn't hear over the sound of other people over-promising.

I think that when one's ideas are unpopular, they're going to get hated on for irrelevant things regardless of whether they're actually that weird. Mary Wollstonecraft was completely discredited when people found out she'd had a baby outside of wedlock. It wasn't that unusual, but people were up in her business to an unusual degree. So at some point you've gotta live your lives and hope the criticism sounds as nasty and mean spirited to everyone else as it does to you. (Seriously, nothing can undermine a point like "look at those WEIRDOS, they have weird sex!" instead of an actual argument.)

Michael Dickens's avatar

This is something I'd been thinking about recently and I was floundering for how to put it, but you put it much better than I could've.

Recently I saw a tweet (forget the author) who said something like, "I have a lot of respect for EAs for making predictions I thought were ridiculous at the time, but then turned out to be right. I just wish they'd stop making ridiculous predictions!" And I was just like, can you hear yourself right now?

57 more comments...

Ready for more?