Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Random Reader's avatar

This is actually an issue that hunters have talked a lot about! I have lived in many rural areas where hunting is common. Here are some important parts of the conversation I've heard:

1. A significant amount of land conservation in the United States was originally driven by hunters. Even to this day, much conservation funding comes from hunting licenses. If you think wildlife habitat is a good thing, hunters will often be among your strongest allies.

2. Hunters are people who spend significant time in nature, paying close attention to nature (if only to find the deer). In general, many hunters really like nature.

3. Many hunting cultures have strong ethical traditions. For example, if I were to shoot the woodchucks damaging my foundation with a .22 rifle, the local hunters would judge me. Woodchucks are basically rodent Terminators, and they survive some nasty injuries, or they die slowly over hours. This is considered a bad death. Ethical hunters care a lot about "clean" deaths. In the case of woodchucks, this means a larger caliber. Hunting wild animals with dependent young is considered especially bad, and may often be illegal. But like any ethical system, there are people who don't follow it. Game wardens actively enforce certain rules.

4. Certain predators hunt livestock or endanger rural children, and are not generally tolerated near humans. But this means that certain common species have no apex predators. White tail deer are a famous example. We can control the population to some extent by issuing doe permits. But in general, deer population is controlled by hunting via stalking. This is probably better than wolves. Also, white tail deer hunters are especially strong believers in clean kills, because deer are charismatic, but also because wounded deer are notorious for running off to die somewhere no sane person wishes to retrieve a large mammal from.

5. Much hunting is for food. For meat eaters, I strongly suspect that hunting via stalking is more humane than factory farming.

6. The people who hunt red tail deer from helicopters are probably not on speaking terms with the people who are judgy about humane woodchuck hunting technique.

7. There are significant differences between hunting and "pest control." Pest control often cares less about being humane.

Ironically, if you aim to reduce animal suffering from hunting, some hunters may be among your best allies, if approached correctly. But again, this will vary by type of hunting.

Quiara Vasquez's avatar

> To be perfectly frank, it is difficult to imagine that much suffering is experienced by an animal that doesn’t realize that she’s being hunted until a bullet goes through her head, killing her within a few seconds. We should all have deaths that painless!

Don't give the utilitarians any ideas!

31 more comments...

Ready for more?