11 Comments
User's avatar
Kristen's avatar

if you are keeping a running database of these guys and know of anybody 30+ in NYC who wants to be asked out, I will ask the ones I am interested in out for myself, and try to set the others up with my single friends…what can I say, I am fearless and love doing God’s work.

Sniffnoy's avatar

I mean hi I have, I think, in fact learned to ask out women I'm interested in (substantially thanks to Ozy!) (possibly still not often enough though?), so if you are, like, deliberately filtering for not doing that, then I don't fit that, but hey I'm here in New York and could certainly stand to meet some new people for this purpose. 😅

I put up something of a short profile here: https://hjaltman.github.io/dmd/ which also links to my account on cuties.app which is a little more informative :P

Doug S.'s avatar

I live in NJ about an hour away from NYC... This gets awkward because when I see something that catches my attention as a way to find people to socialize with IRL it often turns out to be in NYC itself instead of somewhere more local that's easier to get to. :/

tcheasdfjkl's avatar

"If you are plain, fat, or uninterested in doing beauty work, you will likely do better if you ask men out and then win them over with your charming personality." -- man this is true but also it does make it harder bc rejection is likelier

SkinShallow's avatar

I'm as far from the demographic target market for this text as it's humanely possible short of not being a woman interested in men, but hey ho, this kind of thing never stopped me from commenting.

So a couple things.

1) The "lack of default script" is incredibly useful feature that allows for shaping of a specific relationship to one's liking. I think it has limitations (see below) but it can be incredibly freeing. Source: I am a dom with much experience (second hand market/middle age ;) in the BDSM scene (tho kink as such isn't crucial to me). I have ended up with an entirely vanilla man who has much of the sexual wiring that appeal to me without ANY of the "bad habits" or porny expectations that men who identify actively as kinky submissives often/always have. Absolutely delightful.

2) That said. And leaving specifics aside. EVERYONE has a script/default expectations absorbed from culture/environment/media. The only people who don't, or try not to, are ones who decided to actively subvert that default or reflexively question it. So "no experience of dating" might mean no well polished scripts, but doesn't mean no default, likely normative OR RESENTFUL OF NORMATIVE ideas.

3) I'd personally be more wary of men who have strong notions of one's own sexuality/sexual desires as illegitimate or shameful. I think it's not necessarily a big deal with young guys. But each few years of living with that makes that stuff stick more and become hard to dislodge. And while one result might be deep wonder at finding someone who finds them and their sexuality hot and lovable, another result is deeply entrenched shame that's corrosive to relationships, because it creates a hole that's very hard to fill and festering insecurity. The WORST result, and not altogether uncommon (tho more typically applicable to older men with fairly niche interests) is internalising that shame/belief in his lack of sexual legitimacy and deservingness so deeply that finding a woman attracted to him/sharing his desires doesn't trigger adoring gratitude but suspiciousness or disgust.

4) "Talking to people on dating sites and going on first dates with strangers are the most excruciatingly awkward experiences our species has yet invented" -- this is not a comment but a question, is this really true? Maybe because of small numbers, or because I mostly used apps to find playmates, not Big R relationships, but I kinda always liked it, anthropologically even if not for other reasons? Not so much the in app filtering of chaff but once moved off app and especially the meatspace dates, I always found kinda exciting/interesting. So I'm genuinely asking if this is a common opinion.

Simon Kinahan's avatar

For the short period when I was actively dating, I rather enjoyed first dates. First phone calls were pretty terrifying and awkward, but while first dates were scary they were also generally fun after the first few minutes.

Sniffnoy's avatar

I think your #2 is a good point, but, I do think it means it's still more influenceable than it would be otherwise. Although perhaps not always, because some components have means of entrenching themselves ("I expect them to do X, but I can't say that, because if I say that then they'll only be doing it because I said so; and if they attempt to justify them not doing X, well, since X is what they are *supposed* to do, that's just them trying to get out of it and I should ignore that"). But generally I would expect scripts from culture/media to be more influenceable by real life than pre-existing scripts from real life are.

Regarding #4, I think this might largely be a matter of, like, how secure do you feel in your own worth, and also, like, how much do you have the ability to just, like, talk to a person and have a good time with it. Going on a first date with someone you don't know, it's easy to get an awful feeling of, y'know, this person is *judging* me. This person is assessing me, and I have to measure up, and I'm not sure I can. (I believe I recall Norah Vincent writing about this in her disguising-herself-as-a-man experiment.) That was definitely how I first felt. I think once you have a bit of experience, once you're better at talking to people, and once you can, when things don't go great, attribute this not to a fault in yourself but to a tough crowd (so to speak), it's not so bad. But it takes time to get there!

SkinShallow's avatar

I think you're right re 2, easier to modify cultural scripts, as long as they're visible.

Harder if they're assumptions running under the bonnet that will only become clear when something crashes.

mathematics's avatar

On your #4, here's more anecdotal evidence: I enjoy doing things with friends that I know we both like, but I've never enjoyed casual conversation with strangers, whether on a date or in a normal social setting. The first date script I've picked up from society is that the focus of the date is supposed to be on the conversation, with the activity or location just serving as a setting; for me, that has consistently led to first dates that feel like a chore.

I'm not currently trying to date, but when I try again in a few years, I'll probably look for first dates where the activity can be more of a focus - e.g. something where we already have a shared interest. I don't know yet whether that will be enough to make dating enjoyable when the app experience is still so miserable.

SkinShallow's avatar

Yes, I think not having a "default date template" is very useful. I've never had one and while I enjoy conversation and meeting other humans, it's more like interrogation (ok, interview ;) than casual chat 🤣

Jesper's avatar

A propos of nothing, I recently learned about (and joined) a new networking/friend-finding/dating site that I found out via another Substack (Escaping Flatland). The site is called Cuties (https://cuties.app/) and it does away with most traditional dating site things so it might be interesting for others who find those unhelpful. An important part of it is also forming communities around specific interests and websites, EA and LessWrong seem to be pretty well represented. Perhaps there could even be a Thing of Things community on there.