Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Barry Deutsch's avatar

I think that some of the flaws you (correctly) attribute to identity politics, are also as bad or worse with "build shit" politics. Anything that isn't just one individual building shit by themselves is going to end up with most of the important decisions being made by people with free time, education, the ability to navigate bureaucratic systems and talk like an upper-middle-class person, etc..

None of which is to say I disagree with you that there are big benefits to build shit politics! But the way your post is set up, it gives the impression that these problems are reasons that identity politics is worse than build shit politics, when they're probably the same. (Or even worse, since in build shit politics, there might not be any impetus to try and make sure everyone in the room gets to speak.)

How does build shit politics lead to people asking what determined who gets to be in the room deciding which shit to build?

Expand full comment
Isaac King's avatar

> I am can talk like an upper-middle-class person

I don't know whether this was intentional, but if not, typo. :)

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts